This lot is closed for bidding. Bidding ended on 10/21/2011
The New York based Duke Company issued in 1894 what are, arguably, the most visually striking 19th century cabinet cards to promote their “Honest Tobacco” brand. Measuring 6” x 9 ½”, these museum-worthy masterpieces consist of ultra thick cardboard stock and include breathtaking color lithographs of four popular 19th century stars. Unquestionably, the most prestigious of the four players is the majestic Hall of Famer Ed Delahanty in what suffices as his most brilliant cardboard issue in existence. Seldom surfacing in the hobby, the Delahanty Honest Duke cabinet card has eluded even elite enthusiasts with only 4 others encapsulated by SGC and NONE by PSA. Highly condition-sensitive due to their oversized cardboard dimensions, this magnificent SGC 30/2 offering has only been bested by a single SGC specimen with that sole higher-graded copy residing in an SGC 40/3 holder! With all due respect to the legendary Cap Anson, Ed Delahanty cardboard mementos just may be the most coveted 19th century collectibles with none of them emanating the sheer brilliance of this world class marvel. Delahanty’s batting prowess solidifies the immense desirability and value aspect relating to his period keepsakes. In only 15 seasons, “Big Ed” accumulated over 2,500 hits, batted over .400 three times and finished his career with a remarkable .346 lifetime batting average. He also owns the rare distinction of winning a batting title in both the National (Phillies) and American (Senators) leagues. Unfortunately, his career ended in tragedy when in 1903 after allegedly drinking too much, stumbled off a train crossing over Niagara Falls, plunging to his untimely death. Who knows how many more years he could have added to his already Hall of Fame worthy numbers? Yet, synonymous with the immortal Lou Gehrig, Delahanty’s tragic death has solidified his hallowed legacy, forever branding him as a baseball icon with his memory echoing for eternity in Cooperstown, New York. Considering this Delahanty cabinet is rapidly approaching its 107th birthday, the eye appeal of the central portrait image is absolutely breathtaking and unparalleled compared to any other possible cardboard subject via its sparkling array of grey, red and light green hues that vividly define Delahanty’s immortality. With the exception of some diminutive upper left corner edge wear and a peripheral surface chip along the upper left edge, the remaining perimeter is primarily intact with no obtrusive surface flaws/creasing apparent on either side. Most would consent that this magnificent museum-like keepsake easily presents itself in mid-grade fashion, yet due to a previous owner’s “J.C.M.” notation situated on the upper reverse side, the assigned grade is consistent with the technical assessment criteria. Nevertheless, the brilliant Delahanty image is the irrefutable cornerstone of this miraculous offering and is far more prevalent than the technical grade. Furthermore, this awe-inspiring and almost timeless heirloom is an unparalleled testament to our National Pastime’s storied past, effectively transcending us back to an era when baseball’s pure innocence far surpassed its business aspect.